Sonoran Desert
About this Site
General Information
Human Aspects
Physical Aspects
Key Issues
Site Index
Home>>General Information >>State of the Desert Biome Table of Contents>>Urbanization, Uncontrolled Growth and Habitat Fragmentation
 

Urbanization, Uncontrolled Growth and Habitat Fragmentation

Urbanization ranks among the five most-frequently cited pressures on threatened plants of the U.S./Mexico borderlands (Nabhan et al. 1991). Between 1940 and 1990 the populations of Arizona, Baja California Norte, and Sonora shifted from being one half to two-thirds rural, to over three-quarters urban (Table 4). This obviously changes the degree to which the majority of the inhabitants are "in touch" with natural resource conservation issues, but it also poses profound threats for most land, water, vegetation and wildlife resources within a half-hour's drive of the largest metropolitan areas.

The actual effects of this urbanization on biodiversity are many and mutually reinforcing, including the aggravation of the "urban heat island effect" (Balling 1988; Nabhan 1990); the channelization or disruption of riverine corridors; the proliferation of exotic species; the killing of wildlife by automobiles, by toxics, and by pets; and the fragmentation of remaining patches of natural vegetation into smaller and smaller pieces that are unable to support viable populations of native plants or animals.

One of the best-studied cases of the effects of urbanization on natural habitat remnants within the metropolitan grid has been summarized by Nabhan (1990) for Papago Park inside Phoenix, Arizona. Known as Papago Cactus National Monument until 1929, less than a thousand hectares of depauperate natural vegetation remains, surrounded by golf courses, baseball fields, irrigation canals, highways, and tract housing. Most of the park's native carnivores have been killed by traffic, and in the absence of predators other than humans, jackrabbits, cottontails, gophers and ground squirrels have proliferated, particularly as a result of out-migration from artificially watered golf courses and parklands. In sample plots below Papago Buttes, 95% of the palo verde trees one meter tall or more have rabbit droppings under them, and more than half of these "nurse plants" have either rabbit holes or bedding areas cleared beneath them, free of herbs or cacti. Sign of small mammals have become ubiquitous, including gnawing marks on palo verde shoots and cactus stems (McAuliffe 1990).

These unchecked herbivores have devastating effects on the regeneration of the cactus-legume associations in the remnant desert scrub vegetation below Papago Buttes. Jackrabbits and cottontails quickly ravaged a cohort of 150 palo verde seedlings which germinated with summer rains one year, and by the end of the year, the last twelve surviving seedlings were all scarred or clipped by herbivorous jackrabbits and cottontails. Palo verdes are typically the most frequently-used nurse plants by saguaro cacti, but there was no evidence of saguaro recruitment in these plots since 1941. Of the saguaros aged 150 years or younger, 60% had been gnawed at the base by small mammals. Not only saguaro populations, but those of yuccas, chollas and certain herbs have declined precipitously over the last four decades as Papago Park has become a desert island in an urban sea (Nabhan 1990).

During the last forty-five years, the urban heat island effect has caused an increase of 3.9 degrees Centigrade in minimum temperatures, as well as higher wind velocities and greater local evaporation rates (Balling and Brazel 1987). Desert bighorn, badgers and bobcats are no longer seen in the park as they were earlier in the century. Mountain bike trails have proliferated to the degree that not only vegetative cover but topsoil has largely been stripped from the rocky flanks of the Papago Buttes.

From:
Nabhan, Gary Paul and Andrew R. Holdsworth. 1998. State of the Sonoran Desert Biome: Uniqueness, Biodiversity, Threats and the Adequacy of Protection in the Sonoran Bioregion. p.34-36. Tucson, Ariz.: The Wildlands Project.

Sources

(Balling and Brazel 1987)

(Balling 1988; Nabhan 1990);

(McAuliffe 1990).

(Nabhan 1990).

(Nabhan et al. 1991).

Tony L. Burgess and Martha Ames Burgess "Clouds, Spires and Spines," in Tucson: A Short History (1986)

Alberto Búrquez and Angela Martínez-Yrízar. Conservation and Landscape Transformation in Sonora, Mexico. (1997)

 

 

"City development has also taken its toll on nature reserves. The decrees for the Arroyo Los Nogales and the Zona Protectora Forestal de Hermosillo were obliterated and the land sold to developers . This case mirrors the ultimate fate of many nature reserves in Mexico."

-- Alberto Búrquez and Angela Martínez-Yrízar. Conservation and Landscape Transformation in Sonora, Mexico. (1997)

 

"Juanita [an elderly Tohono O'odham woman] has seen rapidly accelerating changes in the Tucson setting, some of them natural events like the flood of 1983, as well as many other man-made 'improvements'... She watches both the constructive and the destructive, both the water-wise gardener who has replanted desert vegetation around his house, and the insatiable developer who plants new housing on acknowledged floodplains, then runs smiling to his out-of-state bank before the next big rains threaten unsuspecting clients."

--Tony L. Burgess and Martha Ames Burgess "Clouds, Spires and Spines," in Tucson: A Short History (1986)

       


Last Updated: November 6, 2002
Page URL: http://alic.arid.arizona.edu/sonoran/documents/nabhan/db_urbanization.html
Credits and copyright information